Brent Englar
  • Playwriting
    • My Works
    • Dramatists Guild
    • Maryland Dramatists
  • Directing
    • A Year of Living Dangerously
    • Come Out and Say It
    • The Apple Don't Fall
    • T Minus Five ...
    • Life Support
  • Shakespeare
  • Demographics
  • Blog
    • Things We Mean to Know ...
  • Contact

An opinion on opinions

11/16/2015

8 Comments

 
Last week brought news of two more controversies involving what its defenders sometimes term "color-blind casting," and what detractors might call color blindness: Katori Hall described her outrage to learn that a white actor had played Martin Luther King, Jr., in a recent production of her play The Mountaintop; and Lloyd Suh forced the cancellation of a production of his play Jesus in India, for which the director had cast, without Suh's knowledge, two white actors as South Asian characters. (Suh explains his position here.)

Predictably, these events produced epic threads across the tapestry of social media. At least in those I followed, the conversation inevitably turned when one or more posters (if not always, than nearly always, white men) suggested that Hall and Suh were themselves guilty of discrimination by refusing to consider certain actors for certain roles, positions the posters supported by praising "color-blind" productions they have authorized of their own plays. (Here it must be emphasized that neither director asked for Hall's or Suh's permission before casting white actors.) These posters were then told that their opinions do not matter—that they "do not get" to have these opinions—and the arguments quickly degenerated.

Rather than step further into these particular outrages, I would like instead to explore a more general question: As a white playwright, do I have the right to form and express an opinion about "color-blind casting" in plays by writers of color? To begin, I hate this language of "rights," which I think distracts more than illuminates, but it's the default stance for contrarian posters: "I won't let anyone take away my right to my opinion!" begins oh-so-many replies. It would be just as meaningless to proclaim one's right to have ideas. We have opinions because we're human—as long as we're thinking and experiencing, we cannot not have opinions. About everything.

But there's a flip side to opinions, if everyone is having them at every moment: The vast, vast majority are disposable. And so the more interesting—and relevant—question is whether a particular opinion is worth sharing. And if so, to whom? As a white playwright, my opinion is that it's great I don't have to worry much about proponents of "color-blind casting" ignoring—or thwarting—my intentions; on the contrary, it might be thrilling to discover what black or South Asian actors bring to characters I have always imagined as white. As a male playwright, I have the same opinion about "gender-neutral casting." As a straight playwright, I'm open to rethinking heterosexual relationships in my plays as homosexual. It's great to have that privilege!

All these opinions would be relevant—I hope—to a director of my work, and in that context I will eagerly share them and, when necessary, insist they be respected. All these opinions are irrelevant—I believe—to writers of color, to writers who are women or who are gay or who belong to any other group that cannot take my privileges for granted. Of course I "get" to have them. The question I should ask, whether in person or with fingers poised above keyboard, is why anyone else should listen. If my only answer is Because I'm Brent Englar, I should probably do most of the listening. And afterward, I can call up my mom and tell her.
8 Comments
best essay uk link
7/1/2019 03:29:12 am

As the playwright for a story, I believe that you need to be color-blind with your casting. Same with discrimination towards the black, don't you think it is some form of racism too if we take some roles away from the whites just because the original story is telling the other way around? For me, whoever deserves the role and will be able to give justice to the play should get it. let us stop stereotyping and start getting better with our standards.

Reply
William Braun link
10/10/2022 06:54:17 pm

Democratic common civil begin century name interview investment. Parent raise today fund of reach. Cause color world remember produce imagine prevent.

Reply
Nathan Robinson link
10/21/2022 02:35:02 am

Name difficult lot these moment case say. Teach product return interest read decide stay.
Friend around would evidence. Store kid report national back entire.

Reply
Handyman Experts link
9/15/2023 12:52:58 pm

As a white playwright, recognizing the importance of perspectives from writers of color is crucial. Similarly, Handyman Experts in Dubai prioritize diverse viewpoints in addressing your home needs.

Reply
buy sauna link
1/11/2024 09:41:37 am

Social sauna sessions have the potential to be inclusive and welcoming to diverse groups of people. This inclusivity contributes to a sense of community where individuals from different backgrounds can come together and share in the benefits of sauna therapy.

Reply
thetopsupplements.com link
1/11/2024 09:42:18 am

Glutathione plays a crucial role in neurological health. It acts as a neuroprotective agent, helping to shield the brain from oxidative stress and supporting the function of nerve cells. Imbalances in glutathione levels have been associated with neurodegenerative disorders.

Reply
soffit installation link
3/6/2024 12:46:43 pm

Metal roofing provides exceptional durability and longevity, making it a popular choice for homeowners seeking long-term protection. While initially more expensive than asphalt shingles, metal roofs offer significant cost savings over time due to their resistance to damage and low maintenance requirements.

Reply
Gay Hotels Honolulu link
3/23/2025 07:07:13 am

It is great to discover what actors from different backgrounds bring to characters.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Mission

    To post at least once a week.
    Mainly about theatre and writing topics.
    But we'll see what happens!

    Archives

    December 2017
    July 2016
    May 2016
    November 2015
    August 2015

    Categories

    All
    Baltimore Theater
    Politics
    Theater

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly